FBTBForums.net

[dWhisper]

Okay, I think we've held out for suspense long enough. Normally, we would have gotten this right out there, but in this case, there were some really phenomenal models, and a tie for first place!

In the end, we decided to break up the tie with a staff vote. And the results are in... there was a winner!

Oh, wait, you want to know who the winner was? Pwah. I just wanted to leave all (okay, some) of the fantastic prizes sitting in my closet! The voting for this was amazingly close. While I'd love to say we had overwhelming turnout on voting, we did have the highest voting turnout in some time.

There were a ton of wonderful entries, and some great examples. This contest grew legs of its own, and flew all over the interweb. Builders were featured on Wired, Gizmodo, and even StarWars.com. The best thing was that it brought in a lot of new members, and more than that, our finalists ran the gambit from crotchety old members like Rocko to several "brand new" bothans!

1st Place.... Nabii's Royal Naboo Air Force 1
(14% of the vote)

Winner of the Clone Trooper AT-AP

2nd Place... RebelRock's TIE SteamFighter
(14% of the vote)

Winner of a Hailfire Droid Set (which will undoubtedly be turned into a castle in the near future... somehow)

3rd Place... ACPin's Jabba's Steampunk Barge
(12% of the vote)

Winner of a nice, shiny AT-ST

4th Place... BigDaddy's Amazing Wheel Bike
(9% of the vote)

A Rebel Scout Speeder will be flying to you.

5th Place... Larry Lars's Y-Wing steamfighter
(8% of the vote)

Fear the Imperial Dropship!
_________________
Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe. - Albert Einstein

[MingoDave]

Congrats to all the winners, entrants, and participants!

But do you know what these numbers mean? 43% of the votes weren't for one of the winners! That the quality of these models was so high that we couldn't pick out a runaway winner is a great thing. Congrats again to all those who clicked the bricks for this one!

[Joedward]

Congrats to all, well done and cheers to everone who entered for making this such a pain in the patootie to vote for.



Although if I'm honest, I think Ologs AT-sTEam should have been in the finalists. Although visualy stunning and wonderfuly built, I can't quite work out what irks me about ACPins model.

But anywho, my $0.02 aside, this contest was fantastic, I can't wait for the next one.
_________________
Jigame

[ZombieSolo]

He did make it to the finals, but these are the top five after public voting.

[Battle Zombie Alita]

[dWhisper]

For those who are curious, these were the final numbers:

Winners
Nabii's - Royal Naboo Airforce 1 (14% - 36 votes)
RebelRock's - TIE Steam (14% - 36 votes)
ACPin's - Jabba's Steampunk Barge (12% - 32 votes)
BigDaddy's - Amazing Wheel Bike (9% - 24 votes)
Larry Lars's - Y-Wing steamfighter (8% - 21 votes)

Runner-ups
Olog's - AT-sTEam (7% - 19 votes)
Motian the Hutt's - Servus I (4% - 11 votes)
monsterbrick's - A.T A.T. E.L.E. Walker (6% - 16 votes)
Thire's - ARC-17 Steamfighter (4% - 10 votes)
kaitimar's - AT-ST (3% - 9 votes)
thwaak's - Imperial London Shuttle (3% - 8 votes)
RocketSeason - "The Empire's Finest" Steam-Powered Speedy Bicycle! (2% -7 votes)
Bohman's - Darling Apollo IV (2% - 6 votes)
R2 Lou2's - Steam Powered Speeder Bike (2% - 6 votes)
jp-30's - Steam Shuttle (1% - 3 votes)
BaronSat's - SteamSpeeder (0% - 2 votes)
D1's - A-Wing (0% - 2 votes)
PJcountach's - Steam I (0% - 0 votes)

Obviously, this represents a good portion of our active community. During the course of voting, new registrations were suspended, preventing anyone from "skewing" the results. Considering we opened voting on several great builds, I know it was tough to pick one. Hell, I could have cast a vote for every one of these models... Don and I basically did when we picked them. But it was all peer-reviewed, so no conspiracy.

Ironic side note... the whole reason we held a staff poll was to avoid the conspiracy thing. That's why it took a bit longer to finish up. Both of the top vote getters offered to step aside for the other builder, so you know.
_________________
Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe. - Albert Einstein

[Clone Assassin]

Congrats to all you builders, winners and runner-ups! This was a fun contest.

[badgerboy]

Dudes! Everyone of you! Amazing stuff. Well done to all.
_________________
brickshelf gallery

[BaronSat]

Congratulations to all the winners, your models are great!

I noted that first and second places get 36 votes each, so how did you choose? I am not trying to create a controversy, I'm just curious.

[R2 Lou2]

Congratulations to the winners, all very worthy in my opinion, and extra big man hugs for Don and dW. The publicity the contest attracted is evidence enough that this was a great idea well executed. Personally, this comp has made me more of an MOCer than i have ever been before and i fully intend to continue working and trying to improve. So, thanks guys for the inspiration
_________________

Brickshelf

[Clonecommando007]

I'm glad Larry Lars placed! He got my vote! Great job with your trashy astro, Larry Lars!
_________________

Visit the Clone Army Builders Guild - www.TheCABG.net

[dWhisper]

[BaronSat]

[ZombieSolo]

He lies, it was a cross between a ferret race and a game of lawn darts... don't ask.

[dWhisper]

Bah, slander and falsehoods! They were stuffed lemmings and it was closer to a game of horseshoes played with ballista.
_________________
Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe. - Albert Einstein

[Nabii]

Well however it was decided (and mighty intriguing those methods are,) thanks very much! I feel pretty amazed to win, I've placed highly here before (under my old log in as Mark Stafford) but never won. I can't praise the other entries highly enough, they were all magnificent!

However it's RebelRock I feel most for - so close... sorry!

As a consolation to him and all the other builders I thought this wallpaper might be nice:
(once the folder is public it's in various sizes - and full colour if you prefer.)


http://www.brickshelf.com/cgi-bin/gallery.cgi?f=304051

Cheers,
Mark.
_________________
Nabii Brickshelf

[Xeta]

You don't know how awesome that picture is ...

Congrats to you winners though (and people who didn't win). I was hoping Servus I would mkae it to the winners circle, but all of you did a great job.
_________________
...

[Motian the Hutt]

Congrats to the top five! This was all around a pretty sweet contest. Thanks Don and dW, for attracting so much attention to our lovely hobby. And nice pic Nabii. Those two winners look great together. Oh and thanks for the sentiments regarding my entry, Xeta. It was thrilling to get the votes that I did get. Well, I wonder what the next contest will be. This'll be tough to top!
_________________
U bah ko ratta kah ba wipa ky is ka chone kawa wookiee.

Flickr
brickshelf

[DestructiveZombie]

Congrats to the winners They were all really well done. Though I'm abit suprised with some of the outcomes.
_________________

DeviantART|Brickshelf

[RebelZombie]

Wow, I thought those care packages full of money and champagne I sent to Don and dW would have paid off. Oh well...


Thanx again for hosting a great contest fellas and congrats to all the winners and participants.
_________________
|)0U{|-|3 |)0U{|-|3===================================

[Zedsier]

First and second were really good models, heehee, it's a TIE, I get it.

I voted for the Imperial London Shuttle, but too bad Motian didn't place. Nifty Slave I variant he had.
_________________

[JediTomM]

HAHA, I just got that, It's a TIE, Hehe
_________________
A million awful things are done to trees. But worst of all... Trees get chained to hippies, Trees get chained to hippies. (song)

Trees by Tripod

[General Veers]

I voted Olog.
But congrats to all of you this was a really fun contest! we don't have enough like it.
_________________
Raptor Fun Fact #73- The raptor's natural enemy is the gas-powered internal combustion off-road vehicle, which is made of evil.

So long everyone, my flight's leaving soon.

[Zombie Fett]

Gratz to the winners. I think larry's Y-wing should have won it looked the best. Ah well now you know who I voted for .

@Joedward: I know what irks me about Acpin's model. Oh sure it's great and all and he has tons of bricks and can build nice stuff but...it just doesn't look steampunk. For one thing the ballons don't look right. And he used string on the ballons and I thought we couldn't use non-lego things?...

Good job Don and dW, you made a great contest and without it I wouldn't be here.
_________________
Oh, signatures are so over rated. =D
Me is dead.
Me has Flickr, does you?

[ZombieSolo]

[BigDaddy]

Thanks for sponsoring this contest, Don and dW! Congratulations to both the winners, and to those who entered.
_________________
The Force is WEAK within you...

[strwrs429]

I love the it's a tie poster, bring on the next contest!
_________________

[CommanderJake]

Congratualtions to all!

Oh, by the way, I do think that Nabii will be recieving an AT-AP, because to the best of my knowledge, LEGO has never released an official AT-PT...
_________________
http://www.ogame.org

[Shifto Canucki]

Congratulations to the winners! It must've been a tough choice for the judges, I know it was for me.

The more important thing is that contests like these serve to galvanize the group and create an atmosphere of mutual inspiration and friendly competition.

When's the next one?

-Shifto

[dWhisper]